But this year there's a shot at redemption with both teams winning through to Sunday's grand final.
They'll have to do it without their goalkeeper though, after Klara Manenica broke her finger last week.
Belconnen also have the pressure of going undefeated with one draw the only blemish on their record.
"They won the grand final last year. That's theirs, no one can take it away from them," Belconnen coach Antoni Jagarinec said.
"It hurt, definitely, at the time, going to penalties. The amount of chances we created in that match and couldn't score against Chantel [Jones] was huge.